Chap. XXIII.—Of giving precepts, and acting

Chap. XXIII.—Of Giving Precepts, and Acting.

If any one gives to men precepts for living, and moulds the characters of others, I ask whether he is bound himself to practice the things which he enjoins, or is not bound. If he shall not do so, his precepts are annulled. For if the things which are enjoined are good, if they place the life of men in the best condition, the instructor ought not to separate himself from the number and assemblage of men among whom he acts; and he ought himself to live in the same manner in which he teaches that men ought to live, lest, by living in another way, he himself should disparage ⁸⁰⁸ his own precepts, and make his instruction of less value, if in reality he should relax the obligations of that which he endeavours to establish by his words. For every one, when he hears another giving precepts, is unwilling that the necessity of obeying should be imposed upon him, as though the right of liberty were taken from him. Therefore he answers his teacher in this manner: I am not able to do the things which you command, for they are impossible. For you forbid me to be angry, you forbid me to covet, you forbid me to be excited by desire, you forbid me to fear pain or death; but this is so contrary to nature, that all animals are subject to these affections. Or if you are so entirely of opinion that it is possible to resist nature, do you yourself practice the things which you enjoin, that I may know that they are possible? But since you yourself do not practice them, what arrogance is it, to wish to impose upon a free man laws which you yourself do not obey! You who teach, first learn; and before you correct the character of others, correct your own. Who could deny the justice of this answer? Nay! a teacher of this kind will fall into contempt, and will in his turn be mocked, because he also will appear to mock others.  

What, therefore, will that instructor do, if these things shall be objected to him? how will he deprive the self-willed ⁸⁰⁹ of an excuse, unless he teach them by deeds before their eyes ⁸¹⁰ that he teaches things which are possible? Whence it comes to pass, that no one obeys the precepts of the philosophers. ⁸¹¹ For men prefer examples rather than words, because it is easy to speak, but difficult to accomplish. ⁸¹² Would to heaven that there were as many who acted well as there are who speak well! But they who give precepts, p. 125 without carrying them out into action, are distrusted; ⁸¹³ and if they shall be men, will be despised as inconsistent: ⁸¹⁴ if it shall be God, He will be met with the excuse of the frailty of man’s nature. It remains that words should be confirmed by deeds, which the philosophers are unable to do. Therefore, since the instructors themselves are overcome by the affections which they say that it is our duty to overcome, they are able to train no one to virtue, which they falsely proclaim; ⁸¹⁵ and for this cause they imagine that no perfect wise man has as yet existed, that is, in whom the greatest virtue and perfect justice were in harmony with the greatest learning and knowledge. And this indeed was true. For no one since the creation of the world has been such, except Christ, who both delivered wisdom by His word, and confirmed His teaching by presenting virtue to the eyes of men. ⁸¹⁶  

Footnotes

124:808

Ipse præceptis suis fidem detrahat.  

124:809

Contumacibus.  

124:810

Præsentibus factis.  

124:811

[See Augustine, quoted in elucidation, vol. vi. p. 541.]  

124:812

Præstare.  

125:813

Abest ab iis fides.  

125:814

Leves.  

125:815

[What neither Platonists nor Censors, in their judgments, could effect by their sophia, the crucified Jesus has done by His Gospel. The impotence of philosophers as compared with the Carpenter’s Son, to change the morals of nations, cannot be gainsaid. See Young’s Christ of History ]  

125:816

Præsenti virtute.